Apple's $930 Million Court Winnings From Samsung ReducedBy cheatmaster 07:13 Sun, 25 Jul 2021 Comments
Samsung and Apple have been tied up in court saga's for quite some time now. The two tech titans have been keeping their legal department busy with all sorts of copycorrect infringements and patent suits, but few can match the scale of the well-known 2012 suit.
If you don't quite remember what all the fuss was about, back in 2012, Cupertino filed a copycorrect infringement suit against Samsung for some of their handsets, at the time. After a long and arduous legal battle, Apple won just under $930 million in damages. A recent court ruling, however, has reversed a part of the fine.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington, D.C has accepted most of the original ruling, carried out by a court in San Jose, California, but has ordered the assumed court to reconsider $382 million of the fine, awarded for "trade dress dilution". As it turns out, part of Apple's case was based on allegations of infringing an unofficial "trade dress" that the US company was using.
The term itself refers to a way a product is presented. This might cover promotional materials, packaging and the sort, but the key thing is that by definition it cannot pertain to any functional parts of a given product. So it is meant for presentation only. Apple, however, was using certain lines from the assumed document, like - "a rectangular product with four evenly rounded corners" and "a flat, clear surface covering the front of the product" in relation to Samsung's current mobile devices, namely the Galaxy S and Nexus S.
On this grounds, part of the fine was reversed and consequently, the court saved Samsung a large part of the settlement. This, however, doesn't mean that the legal ordeal between the two companies is over, far from it. In 2013, after Apple failed to convince the court to problems a ban from selling the accused Samsung phones in the US, thing escalated. A settlement outside court wasn't reached and the Cupertino giant continued to file recent claim against newer devices, like the Galaxy S3.
So, like they say, this battle goes to Apple, but the war is far from over. Whether or not it needs to be stretched out any further is a totally different question. And if you are really keen on reading the court order itself, the full text is in the second source link.
Source 1 | Source 2 | Via
Please LOGIN or REGISTER To Gain Full Access To This Article